Lost Goth Summer 2019: The Magnolia

Image of a woman with long black hair wearing a Magnolia dress in black with tiny pink flamingos scattered like polka dots standing in front of a wall covered by ivy.
The Magnolia

I finished this Magnolia back in September of 2019. At the time, I was healing from feeling forced out of a school that I loved because of terrible administrators. I held on for as long as I could, but the work environment became too toxic. I left a library that I help build, programs that I created from nothing, co-workers that became best friends, and students whom I loved because my physical and mental health were at stake.

I was also having a hard time at my new school. I was feeling out of place and out of sorts, missing the school I had left terribly. Change is hard for me, and this was the biggest change I had to experience in many, many years. Rationally, I knew that I had done the right thing, but emotionally, I was a wreak.

This Magnolia should have been the last of my summer 2019 projects. I had planned my summer sewing and completed three out of the four dresses before summer ended—the Simplicity 3833, the Bexley, and the Myrna. But when it was time for the Magnolia, I ran out of steam. I was too upset and uncomfortable with my new situation; I had no desire or motivation to sew.

Image of a woman with long black hair wearing a Magnolia dress in black with tiny pink flamingos scattered like polka dots standing in front of a wall covered by ivy.
Something Flowy, Pretty, and Happy

And then, one Saturday, I woke up feeling like it was time to make something—something flowy, something pretty, something that would make me feel happy. I picked the cutest fabric I could find, and I started on the Magnolia. I had made a muslin a few months before, so I knew that there were no major adjustments or tricky techniques. The dress almost sewed itself.


Image of the two versions of the Magnolia dress by Deer and Doe
Magnolia Dress, Two Versions

The Deer and Doe Magnolia is a mock wrap dress with two views, one a full-length dress with a plunging neckline and long sleeves, the other a knee-length dress with a more conservative neckline and butterfly sleeves. The Magnolia is stunning, no matter which version you choose. The dress is incredibly feminine, super versatile, and surprisingly easy to sew.

Knee-length Magnolia with Butterfly Sleeves

If you choose to sew the full-length version, be prepared to use a lot of fabric—almost five yards. I don’t know if this is an impediment for anybody else, but I have never purchased that much fabric for one single project. I actually had enough fabric to go for the long one, but I wanted to get at least two projects out of each rayon cut I had, so I picked the knee-length version. Besides, I have not worn a full-length dress since I was a little girl.

Detail of fabric requirement chart
Fabric Requirements


This gorgeous rayon is part of that same fabric haul that has helped birth almost every garment I have sewn since I came back from Brazil in August of last year. I think I bought five yards of five different rayon prints, and I am so happy I did. This is some of the nicest stuff I have ever worked with.

Image of black rayon fabric with tiny flamingos scattered all around
Flamingos Again!

This rayon has tiny pink flamingos scattered all over (I used the same fabric to make a True Bias Sutton), and it is delicious against the skin. It is stable, does not fray, and presses well. If there has ever been a dream fabric, this is it.


Image of measurement size and finished measurement charts
Size Chart

Based on the finished garment measurements, I went with a size 46 for the bust and 50 for the waist. I disregarded the hip measurement since the skirt was not meant to be fitted. In the end, I had to add a bit to both bust and waist, so maybe I should have chosen a larger size. Aside from that, I was quite surprised that I did not have to make any major adjustments to this pattern.


As I mentioned before, the Magnolia is a pretty easy pattern for how stunning it looks. Because I had made a muslin, I knew that I would have to add a bit to the bust area. That was easy because the bodice has princess seams. Princess seams make adjustments much easier to do, but when your bosom is as ample as mine, they can be quite tricky. I found this tutorial by Fashion Hack Patterns, and the tip to trim the princess seam edges by 1/8″ was quite helpful.

I also needed a tiny bit more room on the waist, so I borrowed some fabric from the seams. If I sew another Magnolia, I will go up a size for the waist. I do not wear a lot of dresses that are fitted at the waist, so this might be why I felt it was a bit too snug. I like to have some breathing room, you know?

Side view of a woman with long black hair wearing a Magnolia dress in black with tiny pink flamingos scattered like polka dots standing in front of a wall covered by ivy.
Magnolia, Side View

The skirt is made up of three panels for the front and three for the back. These many panels take a lot of time to sew, but they add a lot of swish to the skirt. I constructed the front part and the back part separately as I was planning to join them at the shoulder to add the sleeves in flat, but the size zipper had me change my plans. I shortened the skirt by a couple of inches because why not?

Image of side zipper
Side Zipper

This was my first time installing a side zipper. I like to sew sleeves in flat as this allows me much more flexibility if I ever need to let a seam out or bring it in. Here, I decided that setting in sleeves was a lesser evil than inserting an invisible zipper after the side seam was sewn. I used the invisible zipper foot, and the zipper went in without a lot of drama—which is saying a lot, considering that zippers are my weakness.

Image of detail of inside of neckline finished with bias
Neckline Finished with Bias Tape

I had to add a tiny stitch where the two bodice pieces intersect because there was a gap—not enough to be scandalous, but enough to make me feel uncomfortable. I should have read Deer & Doe’s post about adjusting the bust before I sewed the bodice, but since the muslin did not have that problem, I skipped it. It looks like the neckline is too long, and pinching a bit of fabric off the shoulder seam would have done the trick. I also feel that since the muslin fabric was sturdier, it just stood in place a little better. The rayon is so drapey, it has no structure at all. Nothing that I can fix now since the neckline is finished with bias tape, and I’m sure as hell not going to undo the whole thing.

Image of a woman with long black hair wearing a Magnolia dress in black with tiny pink flamingos scattered like polka dots standing in front of a wall covered by ivy.
There is a tiny stitch keeping the bodice in check

It has taken some time for me to fully appreciate this dress. At first, I felt uncomfortable, like I had no business wearing it. It just did not feel like me. I needed some time to get used to it. That was the same feeling I had with my new school—a sense of being out of place, of not belonging. I am happy to say that on both accounts, things have changed. I love the Magnolia, and I am much happier at my new school. It is funny how much sewing parallels life.

Image of a woman with long black hair wearing a Magnolia dress in black with tiny pink flamingos scattered like polka dots standing with her back to the camera in front of a wall covered by ivy.
Magnolia, Back View
Image of a woman with long black hair wearing a Magnolia dress in black with tiny pink flamingos scattered like polka dots standing in front of a wall covered by ivy.
Why are flamingos so much fun?


  1. April 23, 2020 / 1:53 am

    It’s always hard to leave a job because of one bad aspect, but in the long run you gotta choose what’s best for yourself. It’s funny how sewjo can just diminish after a period of stress while sewing can also be very relaxing in other times. Anyway, the dress looks wonderful on you, and I love the surprise of flamingos when you come up close 🙂

    • SewGoth
      April 30, 2020 / 10:13 am

      I am happy to have my sewjo back, especially in the middle of this pandemic. I have been able to quiet the mind and focus on something other than the virus. I hope you are doing well in these uncertain times.

  2. Lodi
    April 25, 2020 / 7:59 am

    Great make! I’ve been looking at the Magnolia for awhile. I love a V-neck, and I like the slightly high waist. (Both good features for my figure ‘type’.) I have lots of cotton lawns, but I’m thinking that wouldn’t be flowy enough? Your dress looks perfect in the rayon…and yes, flamingos! (And yes, the pattern is a fabric hog. My favorite dress is long, but I agree that length has limited uses.)
    Hoping your family in Brazil are well, and that it’ll be safe for you to visit this summer.

    • SewGoth
      April 30, 2020 / 10:17 am

      Thanks! I highly recommend the Magnolia. I think a cotton lawn would work with this pattern. I’d love to see what you end up sewing.
      The family is doing well. I talk to my parents a couple of times a week, and we text every day (well, not my dad; he does not believe in cell phones). I hope you and your family are doing well.

  3. April 28, 2020 / 5:31 pm

    Glad to hear you’re feeling better now about the new school. I’m quite the opposite, big life changes usually lighten my mood like I’m high on something for several months, lol.
    Your dress is georgous! I think it suits you so well – and I highly dislike wrap anything (except tortilla wraps and bathrobes), so that is honest, hehe.

    • SewGoth
      April 30, 2020 / 10:25 am

      Change terrifies me! I am such a creature of habit. I really admire people who thrive with change. Maybe the new job will inspire me to take more chances.
      I totally agree on the wrap thing—especially now that I sewed a wrap dress. I figured I would try (since I am stuck at home and why not?), and the result is kinda meh. It is wearable but not something I love. Oh, well, I took a chance, right?
      And I love tortilla wraps 🙂

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *